Which Zelda Style Dominates: Classic or Open World?

The Legend of Zelda is one of the most iconic video game franchises of all time, with a legacy that spans over three decades. Throughout its history, the series has undergone many changes and evolutions, but perhaps none as significant as the shift from classic Zelda to open-world Zelda. With the release of Breath of the Wild, the Zelda formula received a dramatic shake-up that divided fans and sparked a debate over which style of gameplay reigns supreme.

Classic Zelda, represented by titles like A Link to the Past and Ocarina of Time, followed a linear structure with a curated set of dungeons and key items to collect along a predetermined path. Players would progress through a series of dungeons, each with its own unique challenges and puzzles, ultimately facing off against a boss. This formula was refined and improved with each iteration, culminating in the highly acclaimed Skyward Sword.

On the other hand, open-world Zelda, as seen in Breath of the Wild and its sequel Tears of the Kingdom, offers players complete freedom to explore a vast and immersive world. Players are not bound by a linear progression and can choose to tackle the main quest at their own pace or simply get lost in the game’s world. Crafting also plays a major role in these open-world titles, allowing players to gather resources and create their own tools and equipment.

The question of which style of Zelda is superior is a contentious one, with strong arguments on both sides. Classic Zelda fans appreciate the carefully crafted dungeons and the sense of progression and accomplishment that comes with completing them. The intricate puzzles, memorable boss fights, and iconic items like the Boomerang and Hookshot are all hallmarks of classic Zelda.

On the other hand, open-world Zelda proponents argue that the freedom and exploration offered by Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom is a true return to the roots of the series. These games capture the sense of wonder and adventure that players experienced in the original Legend of Zelda, where every corner of the world held the promise of discovery.

Sales and critical reception further complicate the comparison between classic Zelda and open-world Zelda. Breath of the Wild sold more copies than all previous 3D Zelda games combined, indicating the success and popularity of the open-world formula. Both Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom received high aggregate scores from critics, placing them among the best games in the series.

Ultimately, whether classic Zelda or open-world Zelda reigns supreme is subjective and depends on personal preference. Each style of gameplay offers its own unique experiences and appeals to different types of players. However, it’s clear that the open-world formula has brought a new level of excitement and innovation to the series, opening up endless possibilities for future Zelda titles.

As the franchise celebrates its 30th anniversary in the West, it’s safe to say that Zelda will continue to evolve and adapt to new trends and technologies. The formula is not set in stone, and fans can expect to see new iterations of both classic and open-world Zelda in the future. Whether you prefer the structured and linear progression of classic Zelda or the freedom and exploration of open-world Zelda, there’s no denying that the Legend of Zelda will continue to captivate and inspire gamers for years to come.

Source link